Festive book review: The Christmas Cookie Bookshop by Anita Faulkner

(courtesy Harper Collins Publishers)

We have become accustomed through many a Hollywood film, and yes, that even includes the Oscar-worthy dramas which must deliver a quick and happy-ever-after, to think of the trauma of grief as something that is easily dispensed with.

Give it some time, a cosy English village, good friends and a bookshop full of employees like Daniel and Felix who are close friends, and even the most grief-stained of events can recede into the stuff of present=happiness subdued memory.

Ah if only life were that accommodating.

Noémi Blanc, the protagonist of The Christmas Cookie Bookshop by Anita Faulkner, knows that great loss and gnawing sadness cannot be summarily dismissed that easily, and while the daughter of the woman who established a much-loved bookshop in the village of Hazel Blooms in the English Cotswolds has a sweet life running the store now her mother, now living with dementia, has handed over the reins, she cannot leave the events of some two-three years previously behind.

A friend’s tragic accident, which had ramifications through her tight-knit circle of found friends, has seen the previously award-winning cookie maker swear off her sweet craft in favour of playing it safe since while adventures can be intoxicatingly alluring and endlessly exciting, they can also lead to real pain.

And Noémi has had more than her fair share of that, thank you very much; that is until Shay Cassidy arrives in town, a man who does nothing to but pursue adventures for paying guests and who dresses up in a fun costumes as he drums up business with wit and a devil-may-care attitude.

It wasn’t long before Noémi fell asleep on top of her duvet amid an avalanche of decorative pillows, belly full, with a little piece of his heart tucked away inside hers.

He is everything Noémi should not want, and while she makes it very clear that she wants nothing to do with Shay and his dangerously carefree, if enchantingly light and fun ways, she finds herself drawn to him in ways that you know will spell trouble later on for her heart and her avowed intent not to place herself in any sort of emotional jeopardy again.

She tells herself she doesn’t need Shay because she has Fantasy Man to chat to in an online forum when her heart feels too heavily burdened and as someone who shut down and repressed rather than dealing with grief, that is all too often, and he, You’ve Got Mail-style, always has the exact right of sage advice that Noémi needs precisely when she needs it.

Now, there will be no prizes for guessing that Shay and Fantasy Man are one and the same; you can see that happy coincidence coming from a mile away; even so, The Christmas Cookie Bookshop doesn’t suffer from its use of liberally access romcom tropes because there’s so much warmth and heart and quirky connections to sustain the story.

The only slight fault in this otherwise charming book is that Faulkner does over-write Noémi’s fury at Shay’s presence and activities; clearly Noémi is the Meg Ryan to Shay’s Tom Hanks but they’re not in the same industry (save for the fact that they both have shops) and the author is gunning for a delightful friends-to-lovers vibe which she largely achieves but Noémi begins to feel like way too much and you honestly wouldn’t blame Shay for running fast in the other direction.

(courtesy official Anita Faulkner Facebook page)

Thankfully he doesn’t or The Christmas Cookie Bookshop wouldn’t be much of a festive romcom.

What does drive the story is that Noémi has to save her beloved bookshop from all-but-certain insolvency and to do that she has to not only innovate in all the ways that modern bookstores have had to do to keep the online wolf from their book-retailing door such as book clubs, community events and cute gimmicks like blind date with a book, and much of her angst and ill-ease can be explained by being frightened of losing her mum’s legacy after she’s also lost a close friend.

That makes sense, overplayed as it sometimes is at the beginning, and it speaks to the quality of Shay as a person – he’s not perfect and he makes some mistakes and misjudgements especially in the genre-honouring third act where romance may be in peril – that he sees through all that and finds himself falling for his irascible next door neighbour anyway.

The vibe between the two once they do bury the hatchet, and come on, surely you see that coming to (again not in a bad way) is fun and sweet and speaks to the way each heals the other in a way and helps them grow beyond past pain and hurt in ways that don’t feel like an easy fix and have as much of a ring of authenticity as any festive romcom is every likely to achieve.

He [Shay] winked at her, leaving her wondering if his mention of the magic of Christmas was just a joke. But the way he was not eyeing the cookies on the coffee table told her he was serious about that part.

Filled with quirky characters in an archetypal village when everyone looks out for everyone else, The Christmas Cookie Bookshop delivers exactly the sort of warm Christmas hug you need at the end of a long year.

You want Noémi and Shay to realise there’s not argy-bargy between them but the flickering and the fulfillment of love, sweet love, you adore the fact that that Noémi in particular is well loved, care for and supported, and that the village feels like the sort of place, especially at Christmas, that you would love to call home.

People may ridicule the cosy tropes of festive romcoms but what they miss, and what this reader loves dearly, is how much of a refuge from the cold nastiness of life they offer.

Noémi has seen the very worst of life and the great sadness it can bring, as have many of the readers of this bright, burbly book, but The Christmas Cookie Bookshop reminds us that there is hope and the possibility for a happier future, and while it is not easily arrived at, it can be found and luxuriated in once you let down you defences.

And that is what The Christmas Cookie Bookshop is all about – letting down the post-trauma walls you have encircled yourself with, opening your heart and realising that while you have lost a lot, you also have a lot to gain, especially at Christmas when the magical love and hopefulness of being human somehow feels a little more within your grasp.

Related Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.