Festive book review: The Christmas Competition by Zoe Allison

(courtesy Penguin Random House)

Protagonists scarred by life litter festive romcoms like tinsel flung from a tree by an over-enthusiastic cat, their preponderance driven by the fact that nothing is more romantic than a broken person finding healing and wholeness in a new unconditionally loving relationship.

But not all flawed romcom protagonists are created equal and there is a sense sometimes, and this is coming from a reviewer who has been through innumerable hours of therapy and understands how hard it is to simply put your past behind you, no matter how motivated you are (and love is a powerful impelling agent, at least in these books) that some of them simply need to get on with it and stop letting their pasts wreck their presents and cruel the prospect of sunnier futures.

But every so often a protagonist comes along whose inability, initially at least, to surmount the pain and emotional imprisonment of their past, feels rawly authentic and an easily understandable reason why they might stumble when they first encounter true seasonally perfect love.

As someone who underwent significant bullying at school and coercive control from some (thankfully not all by a long shot) people at the church in which I grew up, and has the emotionally PTSD to prove it, I can well understand how the best thing to happen to you can come along and you can still be temped to run a mile in the opposite direction.

Something flashed across his [Kerr’s] features, but I couldn’t tell what from this far away. Hopefully fear. And with that I [Nisa] whirled around and marched back into my house so that I could claim the last word.

Kerr Murdoch, local vet in Inverglen and hunk who looks lustfully good in tight T-shirts – do I mind as a gay man that all the men in hetero romcoms are smokin’, idealistically hot? No, no I do not – is one half of the couple at the heart of The Christmas Competition by Zoe Allison (The Ex-Mas Holidays) and when he finally convinces his neighbour Nisa Ansari from across the road that he isn’t a cat-maiming devil incarnate, he finds the love of his life (well, not right away but c’mon, we all know that’s where the book will go … and of course, we don’t mind a bit) which should be the end of any doubts and temptations to run away, right?

But hush now, the huma psyche is not that easily corralled, and after being abandoned by his mum, mistreated emotionally by his sad and jilted by his girlfriend Aileen – who, rather uncomfortably ran off with Nisa’s husband Drew – he has some major trust and abandonment issues, convinced that everyone in his life is just one moment away from leaving him behind in the dust.

Of course Nisa doesn’t know this, and doesn’t care at first, because as The Christmas Competition opens, she hates Kerr, is determined to beat in the town’s inaugural Christmas house decorating competition and believes he maimed her beautifully contrary kitteh Izzy because that’s what Drew said.

When events conspire to bring the two neighbourly adversaries together and break down the arbitrarily entrenched barriers separating them across just a few metres of bitumen, all that goes out the window in the true tradition of enemies-to-lovers, a tried and true trope in romcoms which Allison uses beautifully in The Christmas Competition.

(courtesy official Zoe Allison Facebook page)

And again, while some romcoms fail to convincingly convey the fact that two people who hated each other’s guts, The Christmas Competition excels in every way, bringing two people with scars and bruises and past pain in ways that fully convince you that they have what it takes to make a brilliant future together.

It’s getting to the future with all that promise and possibility intact that can be the challenge.

While Kerr and Nisa have a delightful time flirting and playfully sparring and doing all the meet-cutey things (though yeah, there’s a convoluted and unusual version of that) that a romcom demands, Allison conveys with real empathy and understanding how hard it can be to take all the buoyant initial promise and turn into something that will go the distance.

Kerr is the one most blighted by the unyielding Ghost of not Just Christmas Past But Every Other Time of the Year Too and it’s his struggle to fully embrace all the promise of his budding relationship with Nisa that fuels the third act of The Christmas Competition which thank the festive romcom gods does not have a showstopping, narrative-shuddering third act schism.

It’s a refreshing resetting of things, which is what most third act schisms are about, and it reinforces how real their connection is without some awkwardly forced confrontation which, after so much promising loving, always feels strangely unnatural.

I smiled, bending my head to whisper in his ear. ‘You are more than enough, Kerr Murdoch.’

I felt his smile graze across my skin.

What really captivates you about The Christmas Competition is that for all its delightful adherence to all the festive romcom cliches you know and love, including home decorating, lavish hot chocolates and the official town tree-lighting ceremony, it feels so wonderfully grounded and real.

Of course, you have all the fairytale falling in love deliciousness you can ask for and it’s fizzy and warm and optimistically gorgeous, but because Allison gives the characters lots of chance to share who they really are and what they’ve gone through, it feels more vulnerably human than many of its festive romcom counterparts.

Though some might fear this will detract from all the confected falling-in-loveness, the truth of the matter is that it enriches and elevates it because here are two very real people finding love and consummating that love (in every way) and giving a firm future footing and their success is finding and keeping love feels so heartfelt and real and possible.

There’s a playfulness to proceedings, powered by sparkling dialogue and richly-realised characters but there’s also life, happiness, love and the joy of seeing two people really get to know each other rather than hiding angrily before false assumptions, and it makes you feel festive and hopeful and joyful and all the very best of things.

But that’s the beauty of falling in love at Christmas isn’t it? It’s a magical time of the year, made all the more so by the emergence of unexpected love, true love, and Zoe Allison pours it with brilliant accomplishment into the festive wonder of The Christmas Competition which will have smiling at how lovely life can be right throughout the season.

Related Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.