(courtesy IMDb)
You do have to feel sorry for festive romcom movies (and Christmas films in general to be honest) which are held to such a high standard of cosy warmth, romantic loveliness and perfect Christmas intangibility that its well near impossible for them to ever come close to reaching it.
We want all the feels, snappy, feisty, witty dialogue, characters with whom we want to spend time sipping eggnog, watching a roaring fire with a glittering Christmas tree beckoning in the corner and going on sleigh rides (with just one horse, naturally; we are nothing if not seasonally appropriate traditionalists).
So, getting a swoon, a sign and 10/10 from anyone is a big ask; and yet, still we ask which makes it fiendishly difficult for movies like Guarding Stars, based on Katherine Center’s 2022 novel The Bodyguard and adapted for the streaming screen by husband-and-wife team Jared and Genevieve Padalecki, to ever truly make the grade.
The slightly disappointing, and I say “disappointing” because in a number of key ways Guarding Stars does tick a lot of necessary festive viewing boxes, is that this film does come close enough to possibly be a contender.
It has all the right ingredients – an independent and eminently capable woman in Hannah Brooks (Leighton Meester) who embodies tough one-eyed professionalism as the titular character of the source book, an A-List movie star in handsome, masculine Jack Stapleton (Jared Padalecki) who’s really a wounded, vulnerable man ahead all the action hero trappings, a cosy family for Jack to return to whom love him unreservedly but who are hurt and wounded by some past collective trauma and the hope and possibility of true love and a real family giving bot Hannah and Jack the healing and all-encompassing domestic bliss they need and deserve.
Phew – that’s quite list; remember what I said about romcoms being held to very high standards? Start with the list of expected elements, of which the previous paragraph barely begins to scratch the seasonally romantic surface.
The thing about Guarding Stars is that it comes reasonably close to hitting that high bar.
This is most especially the case when Jared, who has been distant from his family for quite some time, taking up every role offered to him, losing himself in high profile romances such as the one with massive pop star Kennedy Monroe (Ava Max), decides to spend Christmas with his family.
Hannah has been assigned to him as a bodyguard for one very specific mission, one that is supposed to begin and end within a finite period of time and which is most certainly not supposed to include pretending to be Jack’s girlfriend so mum Connie (Andie McDowell), dad Doc (Shaun Johnston), brother Hank and sister-in-law Ella Mae (Noah LaLonde and Siobhan Williams respectively) and their two cute as a button kids will feel like he’s okay.
Jack wants to make Connie, who’s battling cancer, which may or may not have been subdued into submission by a near-Christmas operation, happy and stress free, and so, with a stalker circling somewhere out there around Jack and meaning him harm, Hannah, who is the daughter of a negligent single mum and who spent her Christmas days alone with ready-made meals and cartoons, agrees to be his date for as much as a Stapleton Christmas will involve.
Which, being a festive romcom, is a LOT.
But thankfully for Guarding Stars that lot actually mostly works; it serves up the festive cosiness we crave from these movies, some key family moments which not only speak to Jack’s need for healing but also why it matters so much, and intimate scenes where the walls erected by both Hannah and Jack against the world, for quite different reasons, begin to slowly drop in favour of love, true love and the encompassing embrace of a near-perfect loving family.
All the tropes are there and Guarding Stars mostly acquits itself well in terms of their inclusion.
That’s often the key test of any of these stories – there’s a laundry list of expected elements that must be included in every one of these films and it can be a narrative noose around the neck or used in ways that feel fresh and original; Guarding Stars really doesn’t re-invent the wheel all that much when it comes to their use but it does employ them well, especially in the family scenes which are mostly strongly moving and all-encompassingly lovely, even if they are a little cheesy at times.
Where it stumbles and feels a little meh in the end is that the inclusion of all those tropes, the very thing that makes it quite lovely to watch at times, also makes it feel a little bland and unadventurous.
It also doesn’t quite land the third act pulling apart and big romantic question mark about whether Jack and Hannah, who are so different and hurt and broken can ever truly be together; there’s enough chemistry between the two leads, with just the right level of cute banter and emotionally raw admissions, for you to want these two lovebirds-in-the-making to finally find a home with each other.
But somehow it all comes together in a film which, while it has some truly affecting moments, again pretty much always when it focuses on the family drama which is quite movingly executed, never really establishes a festive romcom identity and personality of its own.
Thus, while it’s perfectly fine to watch, and you will feel the embers of your romance-craving heart being neatly and pleasingly stoked, Guarding Stars never really levels up to something truly memorable, to a movie you will want to return to time after time, season after season.
As a viewing stocking filler while you wait for the real hopefully excellent streaming presents to come, Guarding Stars is eprfectly serviceable and quote delightful and it will make your cold, digitally battered heart feel a little less Grinchy, Scroogey and cold; but it never truly becomes that festive romcom to end all romcoms, or to even to breath the same heart-stoking air as them which is a pity because the story (and the book from which it is drawn) has everything it needs to become a classic it never really becomes.
A fun interview! Enjoy …
